Employers may violate the FLSA by failing to pay their employees for the total hours they have worked. This may include failing to pay for time such as:
a. time spent cleaning equipment or putting on a uniform before work begins;
b. break time;
c. travel time;
d. time you worked late without being asked to do so;
e. work at home;
The materials found on this website are intended to inform the public, but they are not a substitute for an attorney’s advice about your specific situation. To learn how you are personally affected by the minimum wage and overtime rules, please fill out the online questionnaire by clicking here questionnaire or call: (713) 223-8855.
And many more. To learn more about the time for which you should be getting credit, please view Are you being paid for all hours worked?.
A real case: when the time records are wrong
The case: Anderson v. Mt. Clemens Pottery Co., 328 U.S. 680 (1946) (read the opinion)
The test the court used
- The worker must show he did work that was not properly paid.
- If the employer’s records are bad, the worker can show the amount by a fair, reasonable estimate.
- Then the employer must come forward with exact proof, or show the estimate is wrong. If it cannot, the court can award a fair estimate of the pay owed.
What happened
Pottery workers said they spent time walking inside the plant and getting ready to work that the company’s pay records did not count. Lower courts turned them down in part because they could not prove the exact minutes.
How the court applied the test
- Work done: The Court looked at what the workers actually did, not just the time clock.
- Estimate: It said workers should not lose just because the employer’s records made exact proof impossible.
- Employer’s turn: The employer had to answer a reasonable estimate with real evidence.
The result
The Supreme Court sent the case back so the workers could prove their time under this fair rule.
Keep in mind: Congress passed a law in 1947 (the Portal-to-Portal Act) that changed the part about walking and getting ready. Today, this case is used for the rule about bad records, not as a promise that all walking time is paid.
A recent case: rounding that costs workers time
That case shows how the law treats bad time records. Here is a recent decision about a timekeeping practice that quietly shaves minutes off a paycheck.
The case: Houston v. Saint Luke’s Health System, Inc., No. 22-1862 (8th Cir. Aug. 11, 2023) (read the opinion on Justia)
Who the workers were and what they did
The workers were hourly employees of a hospital system whose time was recorded on an electronic clock. The opinion does not name a specific job title.
What the employer did
If an employee clocked in or out within six minutes of the scheduled shift time, the system rounded the time to the schedule. The employer said rounding evens out over time.
What the court decided
The workers’ expert showed large total losses of paid time, including overtime. The employer’s own analysis showed that many employees also lost time. Because of that evidence, the employer could not win without a trial just by saying the rounding was neutral.
The result: The court threw out the employer’s early win and sent the case back.
Keep in mind: The court did not ban all rounding and did not award damages. It looked at how this policy worked in practice, not just how it looked on paper.
This is the kind of unpaid-overtime problem we help employees with, in courts across the country. If your workplace looks like the one in this case, tell us what happens on your shifts and we will tell you honestly whether you may be owed pay.
Free & Confidential — No Fee Unless We Win
Ready to Recover Your Unpaid Wages?
Overtime claims have strict legal deadlines. Contact Tran Law Firm today for a free, confidential case review with no obligation.
800 Town and Country Blvd Ste 500, Houston, TX 77024 — Nationwide Representation